One blizzard. Different New Yorks.
The January 2016 blizzard left strikingly different totals even among New York City's official observing locations.
Measurements apply to their named reporting locations.

The coastal storm produced major snowfall around New York, with distinct observations retained for individual reporting locations.
Read the original historical coverageNational Weather Service New York · retrospectiveSources & event details
Regional event · New York City, Long Island, northeast New Jersey and southwest Connecticut. Each total belongs to its named station.
Central Park: 27.5 inches · storm-total snowfall. Measurement source ↗
JFK Airport: 30.6 inches · storm-total snowfall. Measurement source ↗
LaGuardia Airport: 28.2 inches · storm-total snowfall. Measurement source ↗
January 22-24, 2016 Blizzard ↗
National Weather Service New York
A regional storm does not establish the first seasonal snowfall at your city.